ET: Engine (Twin) Camshaft design

Bill Thomas

Well Known and Active Forum User
VOC Member
Cannot now remember what happened to it but Ian Hamilton did have a one piece forged crank together with a pair of titanium rods. It was never built into an engine , the crank had not been finish ground, but it was used as a very expensive doorstop in the workshop for several years. It was another one of those ideas we never took to completion.
Morning Jim, Was it you, And if it was, Did you ever do anything with the single side, Honda ? rear swingarm, From the stevenage rally, Many years ago. Cheers Bill.
 

eglijim

Well Known and Active Forum User
VOC Member
Hate to tell you how long Bob has had both of my twin engines, suffice to say it is not a single number of years. The Comet special is being finished by Bob for May, Glenn Cs widow.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20171223_115426536.jpg
    IMG_20171223_115426536.jpg
    3.2 MB · Views: 45
  • IMG_20171223_115501886.jpg
    IMG_20171223_115501886.jpg
    3.3 MB · Views: 46
  • IMG_20171223_120200480 (1).jpg
    IMG_20171223_120200480 (1).jpg
    3.5 MB · Views: 44

BigEd

Well Known and Active Forum User
VOC Member
VOC Forum Moderator
This thread is "camshaft-design". I've moved a few posts to a new thread titled "Waiting for work to be completed". (Click the bold text to go to the thread.) Please try to start a new thread if you have strayed too far of topic. It makes things so much easier for people looking for information about a specific item if they don't have to wade through a load of posts that are off topic. Thank you in anticipation ....... :)
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member 3831

Guest
When discussing camshaft design, no one as yet has made comment on rocker flex, and how it will affect the valve lift curve. The Vincent rocker is extremely weak from the stiffness viewpoint, and the amount of flex that occurs in a running engine is considerable. If this is not allowed for in the static design, the end result will always be considerably reduced dynamic valve lift curve
Has anyone tested a rocker to see how much it flexes ? For those interested the attached illustration shows the method. If the X1 dimension is 300 mm, and the X2 dimension is 50 mm, an 8 to 10 Kg weight is sufficient, but the measured flex will be an alarming amount.
For a really stiff rocker, the flex should ideally be 0.002" but up to 0.007" is passable, and above 0.007" the valve lift loss will start to become excessive.
The flex is due to the lack of depth in the arms, and the inadequate material around the pivot.
This situation is impossible to realistically improve on while still retaining the stock installation arrangement, but the modified rocker mounting illustrated in an earlier post presented an ideal opportunity to improve the rocker stiffness dramatically. Unfortunately in the photo it seems not to have been done.
 

Attachments

  • measuring stiffness.jpg
    measuring stiffness.jpg
    39.3 KB · Views: 26
D

Deleted member 3831

Guest
The steel selected for the rockers must be pretty good to not fail in high mileage motors.
The rocker flex, although it may be considerable, is nothing compared to that occurring in a valve spring when it is is compressed.
If you consider that all metal components of an engine are made of some sort of rubber, you should get the idea - added to which they will all expand when subjected to heat.
 
Top